6+ Delicious Plum Tomato Substitutes

Rate this post

For cooks, no tomato is more revered for its adaptability than the plum tomato. This well-known tomato is also associated with Italian cuisine and is used in a variety of recipes. If you’re looking for a plum tomato alternative, keep reading to locate the greatest possibilities.

What Are Plum Tomatoes?

Because of their low water content, excellent acidity, and appropriate sweetness levels, plum tomatoes provide the foundation for the greatest tomato-based sauces. Moreover, the low water content of plum tomato makes it ideal for developing the correct consistency for pastes and sauces.

Plum tomatoes, which are distinguished from other tomatoes by their rectangular shape, contain few seeds and are most often found in the canned goods area of supermarkets.

Also, if you need an alternative, you should know that finding an appropriate substitute for plum tomatoes isnt difficult since they are available in more items than you may imagine.

These are your choices.

Substitute For Plum Tomatoes: Best Options

1. Canned Tomatoes

You may use canned plum tomatoes for fresh plum tomatoes in any recipe.

You may also find canned diced tomatoes in your cupboard or at the shop. They are nearly typically plum tomatoes that have been pre-diced and prepped for use in recipes that call for diced tomatoes.

They are a fantastic replacement for plum tomatoes in any setting.

2. Tomato Puree

Tomato puree is an excellent substitute for plum tomatoes, since this sauce is often prepared using cooked and reduced plum tomatoes.

With tomato puree, you get the normal taste but not the texture, which may be useful in a variety of dishes such as homemade tomato sauce. Just make sure you have pure tomato puree with no extra additives.

3. Campari Tomatoes

Campari tomatoes are medium-sized tomatoes that are recognized for their juicy and sweet flavor. They have a higher water content than plum tomatoes, however this may be mitigated by boiling them for longer to enable more liquid to flow and diminish. You may also smash them during cooking to make them more comparable in consistency.

Although camparis may not have the same taste as conventional plum tomatoes, they are an ideal replacement due to the texture and consistency similarities.

Sadly, many alternatives do not provide the semi-liquid smoothness that plum tomatoes provide in recipes such as marinara sauce. That’s where campari tomatoes shine as a plum tomato substitute.

4. Tomato Paste

Tomato puree’s thick and dense cousin! Tomato paste is a rich plum tomato-based paste that may be combined with other ingredients such as tomato puree, water, and whole tomatoes to make bases for pizzas, sauces, and other dishes.

Tomato paste may be used in place of plum tomatoes in meals such as lasagna and basic pasta sauces. It’s a rich and flavorful plum tomato substitute that you shouldn’t pass up.

5. Grape Tomatoes

Grape tomatoes, unlike tomato paste, do not have the same depth of taste. Instead, you will get a tomato that resembles a little plum tomato.

Grape tomatoes are larger than cherry tomatoes and less sweet, making them a superior substitute for plum tomatoes in recipes.

Although they don’t have the same taste as puree or paste, they do offer texture for those looking for the correct consistency from a swap. Because of this, grape tomatoes are a fantastic mid-ground choice, providing the best of both worlds without sacrificing taste or texture totally.

Sadly, grape tomatoes may be difficult to get in supermarkets, particularly when they are out of season. It is, ultimately, the only reason they are not higher on our list.

6. Beefsteak Tomatoes

Last but not least on this list are beefsteak tomatoes, which may be used in lieu of plum tomatoes in cooking sauces and crushed tomatoes.

The beefsteak tomato, like plum cultivars, has a reduced water content and fewer seeds. Apart from size and appearance, the major distinction between the two is taste. Since beefsteaks have a softer taste, chefs choose plum tomatoes.

Having said that, they might be a great replacement in sauces where you’ll be adding more components.

When seeking for a fleshier sauce, use plum tomatoes for beefsteaks and vice versa.


Other tomatoes, such as the very sweet cherry tomato, are not viable substitutes owing to their high water content, which may unbalance your meal. Also, the rough skins of sun-dried tomatoes might impart bitterness to your meal, necessitating the need to adjust your acidic tomato sauce.

It is important to note that popular options such as Roma and San Marzano tomatoes are really plum tomatoes.

Any of the possibilities on this list will serve as a workable substitute, and for the appropriate recipes, they will be an outstanding substitute.

Must-read related posts

  • Tomatoes in place of canned This may seem like the ideal solution for you, but if you don’t have any on hand, you may want to look at canned tomato substitutes.
  • Tomato Varieties Explained It’s sometimes useful to receive a brief review on how and why various tomatoes are utilized. This amazing instruction will help you improve your understanding in about two minutes.


What is a good substitute for plum tomatoes?

Here are five plum tomato replacements that can still provide a great tomato taste to your meal.
Tomatoes in a can.
Tomatoes with Campari, no. 2.
Tomato paste (no. 3).
Tomatoes from a beefsteak.
Grape Tomatoes are number five.
Feb 26, 2023

Can I use chopped tomatoes instead of plum tomatoes?


If the recipe asks for chopped plum tomatoes, you may break them up in the pan using the back of a wooden spoon to produce a similar texture.

Are San Marzano tomatoes similar to plum tomatoes?

San Marzano tomatoes are a type of plum tomato with an elongated shape. They are highly valued in Italy and throughout the world for their thick flesh and sweet flavor.

Are whole canned tomatoes plum tomatoes?

Let’s begin with the biggest, entire plum tomatoes. This is a can of whole tomatoes filled with juice. They are peeled so that they are fully skinless, yet they retain all of their seeds. Several individuals use entire tomatoes in their spaghetti sauce, crushing them in their hands before adding them.

Is there a difference between plum and Roma tomatoes?

In summary, the Roma tomato is one of the most well-known types of plum tomato. It is also known as the Italian plum tomato. As a result, they are at various degrees of categorization identification. While the roma is a kind of plum, not all plums are romas.

What’s the difference between tomatoes and plum tomatoes?

Plum tomatoes have a lower moisture content than cherry tomatoes. The sweet acid taste and delicate texture of plum tomatoes ensure that you will have the ideal tomato sauce. In addition, plum tomatoes contain less seeds than cherry tomatoes. As a result, they are a superior choice for sauce producers.

What’s the difference between plum tomatoes and regular tomatoes?

Because of their specialized uses, plum tomatoes are also known as processing tomatoes and paste tomatoes. In contrast to the spherical form of normal tomatoes, plum tomato shapes range from oval to cylindrical. Also, the size of the fruit varies according on the type.

Can you substitute cherry or grape tomatoes?

Can I Switch Between Them? For most dishes, such as salads, cherry and grape tomatoes may be used equally; however, since cherry tomatoes are bigger, you may need to chop them into smaller pieces.

Is a grape tomato a plum tomato?

Grape tomatoes are little plum tomatoes (comparable in size to cherry tomatoes).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *