Anaheim Pepper Substitution was the answer.

Rate this post

An Anaheim pepper is a mild-flavored chili pepper called after the city in Southern California where it first gained popularity, Anaheim. Because of their origins and relatively obscure status, the delectable peppers might be difficult to locate in certain locations. If you need an Anaheim pepper substitution for a recipe, keep reading to learn about your possibilities.

What Are Anaheim Peppers?

Anaheim peppers may reach a length of 10 inches and a heat unit of 2500. They are often used green, but may ripen to red. They may also be purchased in stores dried, roasted, fresh, or tinned.

While they are widely accessible over the globe, there may be times when a replacement for Anaheim Pepper is required. Maybe you want something a little spicier, or you just can’t get this sought-after pepper in your area. These are some alternatives to Anaheim Pepper.

Best Substitutes for Anaheim Peppers

1. Poblano Peppers

The Poblano Pepper is native to Puebla, Mexico. These peppers have the same amount of heat as Anaheim peppers.

Despite their dissimilar appearance, Poblano peppers are an excellent alternative for Anaheim peppers. They have a moderate taste with just the right amount of spice. Since they have a wider cavity, Poblano Peppers are ideal for stuffed recipes.

When it comes to flavor, Poblano Peppers are earthier than Anaheim Peppers. Furthermore, although Anaheim Peppers have a crisper texture, it won’t make a difference in your recipe.

2. Bell Peppers

If you don’t want anything spicy, this is the great option. While they might not taste the same, Bell Peppers are a healthy and tasty substitute for Anaheim Peppers.

Bell peppers come in a variety of hues, including yellow, green, red, and orange. Apart from adding taste, they will also provide color to your food. They’re also great for stuffing since they have a thick, meaty flesh wall to contain stuffing components.

Another advantage is that bell peppers may be eaten either raw or cooked. They also include important antioxidants that keep the body running smoothly.

3. Jalapeño Peppers

This is another popular Mexican pepper, much more so than the Anaheim Pepper. The Jalapeo resembles a regular chili pepper but is somewhat spicier. And the texture and taste are similar to those of an Anaheim pepper.

These are not the same form as Anaheim Peppers, but they have the same fresh earthy taste and are much sweeter.

You may need to lower the heat by removing the Jalapeo Peppers seeds and ribs when using these peppers as a replacement. Jalapeo peppers go well with rice dishes, salsas, and stuffed appetizers.

4. Hungarian Wax Peppers

If you want a super-hot substitute for Anaheim Peppers, these spicy Hungarian pods are your best alternative. Hungarian Wax Peppers are about 20 times hotter than an Anaheim Pepper.

Hungarian Wax Peppers may be used in place of Anaheim Peppers. They’re fantastic for stuffing recipes. And, according on your preferences, they may be roasted, baked, dried, or even pickled.

Please keep in mind that this pepper has an acidic, sour taste that may affect the flavor of your food.

5. Serrano Peppers

Another wonderful choice is the Serrano Pepper. They share the same smokey taste as the Anaheim Pepper, despite their differences in spiciness.

You may chargrill or roast them before eating them for a milder flavor. You may also add other spices to slightly lower the heat. Serrano peppers are excellent for salsas and sauces.

Related: What Is the Best Serrano Pepper Substitute?

6. Fresno Peppers

Fresno peppers are similar in form and size to Anaheim peppers, but they are spicier. They’re similarly similar to Jalapeo peppers, except they’re usually red in color.

If you wish to avoid the heat of the Jalapeo replacement choice, these spicy pleasures are an excellent alternative. They also have a fruity and sweet flavor similar to the Anaheim Pepper.

7. Guajillo Peppers

Guajillo peppers have a distinct flavor and taste, making them ideal for Anaheim pepper dishes.

They have a sweet and smokey taste, similar to Anaheim Peppers. Yet, the Guajillo Pepper is hotter than the Anaheim Pepper. They are also suitable for roasting and stuffing preparations.

Alternatives for Guajillo Peppers

8. Shishito Peppers

This East Asian chili is also a fantastic Anaheim Pepper alternative for recipes like stuffed peppers. Shishito peppers are moderate and somewhat spicier than bell peppers. As a result, its taste is comparable to that of the Anaheim Pepper but less fiery.

These peppers may be used raw in salsas, grilled, fried, or baked. If you can locate them, they make an excellent alternative for their adaptability.


That’s all there is to it. When you’re in a pickle, these are the 8 finest Anaheim Pepper replacements. Several of these alternatives should be readily available at your local grocery shop. And there’s something for everyone, whether you like your cuisine spicy or not. Nonetheless, the aforementioned alternatives are likely to knock your socks off.


What can I use instead of dried Anaheim chili?

The ideal substitute: poblano pepper

They both have only a smidgeon of heat, with Anaheim having a somewhat higher potential for more. The Scoville heat unit varies from 1,000 to 1,500 for the poblano and 500 to 2,500 for the Anaheim.

What’s another name for Anaheim pepper?

Anaheim peppers are also known as “New Mexico Chilies” or “Hatch Chili Peppers” since they originated in New Mexico. According to legend, they came in California when a farmer called Emilio Ortega carried the seeds to Anaheim in the early 1900s.

Is Anaheim pepper same as Serrano?

Serrano peppers are a kind of chili pepper that has a spicy and intense taste and normally registers between 10,000 and 25,000 heat units on the Scoville Scale. Anaheim peppers are a mild chili pepper that usually registers between 500 to 2,500 Scoville heat units on the Scoville Scale.

What can I substitute for Anaheim poblano pepper?

Jalapeo Chili

Since they have a similar flavor profile, jalapeo peppers are a decent alternative for poblano peppers. They’re also a wonderful option for folks who want a little spice in their food but not too much.

What flavor is dried Anaheim pepper?

Anaheim Chiles are dried versions of Red Anaheim Peppers. They have a thin body with an earthy chile taste and wild cherry overtones. This slightly spicy chile is grown in Mexico and varies from 2 to 4 on a heat scale of 1 to 10. Scoville heat units range from 8,000 to 12,000.

Which is hotter Anaheim or poblano pepper?

Green Poblano Chiles

It is normally hotter than Anaheim, however its pungency fluctuates and it may be relatively mild at times. Poblanos are frequently utilized in a variety of dishes across Mexico, and they are the most often used peppers in the creation of chiles rellenos and chiles en nogada.

What is closest to Anaheim pepper?

Finest Anaheim Peppers Substitutes.
Bell peppers. If you don’t have a strong tolerance for heat, bell peppers are the ideal anaheim pepper replacement. Poblano Peppers. Jalapeno Peppers. Hungarian Wax Peppers. Chilaca Peppers. Fresno Peppers. Guajillo Peppers. Shishito Peppers.
Additional details…•November 1, 2022

What is Anaheim pepper compared to?

Anaheim chiles are a pleasantly spicy pepper with a Scoville heat unit range of 500-1000. (SHU). On the Scoville Scale, they are around 5-16x milder than a jalapeo.

Are Big Jim and Anaheim peppers the same?

The Big Jim Chile Pepper, developed in 1975 at New Mexico State University, is the biggest of the New Mexican pod kinds, formerly known as Anaheim, California, or green Chiles.

Are Anaheim hotter than jalapenos?

The Anaheim is typically a moderate spicy chili, with Scoville heat units ranging from 500 to 2,500. As compared to our jalapeo reference point, Anaheims vary from same heat to 15 times milder.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *