Caraway Seed Alternative

Rate this post

Caraway seeds have to be the most flavor-packed seasoning. Caraway seeds, on the other hand, may not be your cup of tea. In such situation, a caraway seed alternative may be required.

Caraway seeds have a distinctive taste. These seeds provide a toasty and rich flavor to recipes. They have a slight peppery flavor with licorice undertones. And you’ll find them in dishes like rye bread, spice pudding, and sausages from Germany, Eastern Europe, and the Middle East.

It might be difficult to locate due of its peculiarity. Yet, if you want to make a meal that calls for caraway seeds, these are the finest caraway seed substitutes.

What Are Caraway Seeds?

Caraway seeds are somewhat unknown. These seeds grow from the Carum Carvi blooming plant and are harvested across Europe and Southeast Asia.

They are very fragrant and have an unique citrus and licorice taste. Most European and Middle Eastern recipes include the seeds. Caraway, for example, is a key ingredient in the Tunisian cuisine harissa.

They are quite popular because to their anti-inflammatory qualities and as a source of vitamins A, E, and B-complex. These seeds also have digestive properties and antioxidants that improve intestinal health.

Caraway Seed Substitute

Numerous alternative choices might deliver the same taste as caraway seeds. Most of these substitutes are likely to be found in your kitchen.

1. Fennel Seeds

Fennel seeds have a distinct rich nutty flavor that is popular in Indian and Middle Eastern cuisines. They are great alternatives because to their pronounced licorice undertones, which mirror the distinctive taste of caraway seeds.

They are, nevertheless, significantly sweeter than caraway seeds. Fennel seeds, on the other hand, are often a tasty addition to foods like curries and stews.

When replacing fennel seeds for caraway seeds in a recipe, use a 1:1 ratio.

2. Dill Seeds

Dill seeds are another excellent replacement. The majority of people are acquainted with their distinctive bright and fresh taste. Nonetheless, they have a milder licorice flavor than caraway seeds.

These seeds are an excellent substitute in a variety of dishes, but they are especially tasty in salad dressings. Yet, they do convey significant taste overtones. Yet, it might enhance the citrus taste of your food.

Caraway seeds may be replaced in equal amounts with dill seeds.

3. Anise Seeds

Anise seeds are the most effective caraway seed alternative. They have comparable licorice flavors and are related to the carrot and parsley plant families.

If you’ve ever smelled anise seeds, you’ll notice they have a strong fragrance. Nonetheless, they lack the essence of caraway seeds’ powerful fragrant overtones.

Anise seeds may be used as a flavoring substitute in cookie and bread recipes. Another alternative is to steep them in tea or eat them as a snack after a meal to help digestion.

Keep in mind that anise seeds have a more intense taste. As a result, a little goes a long way. Begin with a teaspoon for each teaspoon of caraway seeds. Add a tiny quantity at a time until you obtain the desired flavor.

4. Nigella Seeds

Nigella seeds, also known as black onion seeds or charnushka, have been around for generations. These small black seeds have savory licorice flavors and make an excellent substitute.

They do, however, have a mild bitterness and a toasted onion taste. There is also a lack of the distinct citrus taste present in caraway seeds. Nonetheless, they seem extremely similar, making them an easy substitute for a variety of cuisines ranging from curries to naan.

For the best results, substitute one tablespoon of caraway seeds with one tablespoon of nigella seeds.

5. Star Anise 

The caraway seed has a licorice taste. Eventually, there’s star anise. At first look, they seem to be small stars with eight cloves. This unusual component is full of flavor and serves as the aniseed.

Star anise, unlike caraway seeds, combines a little bitterness with sweet, pleasant aromas. This makes it great for anything from savory recipes like curries to sweet baked goods.

One thing to keep an eye out for is its powerful taste, which may be overbearing in some dishes. Begin with a tablespoon of star anise and a tablespoon of caraway seeds. You may need to crush entire star anise to prevent biting into a huge chunk of anise.


While caraway seeds have a unique taste, there are other spice substitutes available. There may be a tiny taste change, but they will suffice in a hurry. Finding a caraway seed alternative will be as simple as pie with the following list.


Can cumin be substituted for caraway seeds?

Sure, you may use cumin as a replacement for caraway seeds. Although they have distinct tastes, cumin may be used as required. Cumin may stand in for caraway seeds in stews, curries, and sauces due to its warm feel, peppery aroma, and unique combination of earthy, nutty, and lemony flavors.

Can I omit caraway seeds?

Fennel, dill, anise, or nigella seeds are excellent substitutes for caraway. If you’re in a pinch, star anise is another option, but use it sparingly. Cumin is suitable for savory meals that need a spicy, warming flavor; nevertheless, the dish will taste different.

What is the flavor of caraway seeds?

The caraway seed flavor is mostly nutty, although it is also sharp. Caraway has a bittersweet taste profile with undertones of anise and lemon. Caraway seeds complement the flavors of chives, thyme, cumin, parsley, and dill.

Are cumin and caraway the same?

Caraway Seeds vs.

Caraway and cumin seeds resemble one other in appearance, yet cumin seeds are lighter in color and less curled. Yet, the two spices taste quite different: cumin has a warm, earthy, somewhat spicy flavor, and caraway has distinct licorice and citrus undertones.

What can I substitute for caraway seeds in Irish soda bread?

What is the finest caraway seed substitute? Fennel seeds, like caraway seeds, are members of the carrot family. Fennel has a unique flavor and does not taste exactly like caraway, although it does have licorice undertones and a comparable essence. Caraway seeds may be replaced with an equivalent quantity of fennel.

Can I substitute coriander for caraway?

Caraway plant fruits, sometimes known as seeds, are offered dried in whole or crushed form and may be used in place of coriander. Nevertheless, since caraway has a distinct taste profile than coriander, start with a tiny quantity and add more as required.

Do caraway seeds add flavor?

Toasted caraway seeds complement breads, soups, stews, salads, roasted potatoes and sweet potatoes, coleslaw, baked apples, pig roasts and chops, cheese dips, and other dishes.

How important is caraway seeds?

Caraway is high in vitamins and minerals. Unfortunately, the same factors that make caraway so strong may also cause health problems in those with specific medical conditions. Caraway seeds have the ability to help decrease chronic inflammation, which is one of its most intriguing qualities.

Can I substitute coriander seeds for caraway seeds?

Coriander seeds, with their lemony, woodsy, earthy, and licorice-like flavor, are an excellent substitution for caraway seeds. The perfume of this plant is similar to that of cumin and fennel seeds. Coriander seeds, on the other hand, have a sweeter, more delicate, and less pungent taste than caraway seeds, making them more flexible.

Are caraway seeds in everything bagel seasoning?

In the early 1980s, the everything bagel was conceived and popularized in or around New York City. Poppy seeds, sesame seeds, onion flakes, caraway seeds, garlic flakes, coarse salt, and pepper are common ingredients in the flavor blend.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *