Substitute For Banana Peppers

5/5 - (1 vote)

There is no garnish that is superior than crispy banana pepper rings for sprinkling on your nachos. However, you could find it necessary to look for an alternative since it’s not always easy to get your hands on them in shops. Because of this, it is a good idea to have an appropriate replacement for banana peppers on hand at all times.

Because of their big size and yellow, banana-like look, banana peppers, which are also known as banana chilies, have been given this moniker. These peppers have a wide variety of applications in Mexican cooking and are a staple ingredient in that cuisine. However, you can often purchase them pickled in your neighborhood grocery store, either in their whole or sliced into rings.

This article will examine the finest substitutes for banana peppers to use in situations when you either can’t get your hands on banana peppers or you just want to try something new.

What are Banana Peppers?

The origin of banana peppers may be traced back to South America. As a consequence of this, banana peppers are often used in the cooking of South American countries, most notably Mexico. However, it is important to emphasize that while they have the appearance of bananas, they do not taste in the least bit like bananas.

These peppers have a sweetness to them, and their heat level, which is assessed at roughly 500 SHU, is quite low. It would be more accurate to characterize them as bright and tangy peppers rather than fiery ones. Banana peppers, despite this, have a pleasant flavor and may be consumed either raw, roasted, or pickled.

It would seem that pickled banana peppers are more widely accessible than their fresh counterparts. The pickled type, on the other hand, is most often used as a topping for sandwiches, tacos, nachos, pizza, and a wide range of other dishes.

Fresh banana peppers are often filled with cheese, meat, or vegetables due to their size and their thick, meaty walls. Banana peppers may be found in grocery stores. In point of fact, you can do practically everything with banana peppers, including everything you can do with bell peppers and jalapenos.

Substitute For Banana Peppers

If you want to raise the amount of heat in your meal, you may want to find an alternative to banana peppers. Or maybe the banana peppers you’re looking for at your neighborhood grocery store are nowhere to be found. In any case, we offer a number of wonderful options that you may choose from instead.

1. Bell Peppers

The plain old bell pepper is probably the most similar thing to a banana pepper that you can get. Even though they don’t have the same outline, the thickness and robustness of their walls are same. In addition, they provide a taste that is soft and somewhat sweet. However, the acidic flavor of the banana pepper is not present in these peppers at all.

Bell peppers of any color, whether green, yellow, or red, will do well in their place. In addition, they are ideal for stuffing with various ingredients including meat, veggies, rice, cheese, and so forth. In addition, bell peppers are often consumed in their uncooked form. Therefore, they are an excellent choice if you are searching for an alternative topping to use on tacos, sandwiches, or salads.

2. Cubanelle Peppers

Banana and bell peppers are the parents of the fruit that is often referred to as cubanelle peppers, which are also known as Cuban peppers. In general, they are about the same length as a banana pepper but somewhat wider. When unripe, they have a light green color, but when they’re ready to eat, they may be orange or brilliant red.

You probably already knew that this pepper is used often in Cuban cookery, but did you know that it’s also a beloved ingredient in Italian cuisine? Sweeter and less hot than banana peppers, Cubanelle peppers have a wall of flesh that is thinner than that of banana peppers. Because of this, they may not be ideal for stuffing, but they are wonderful for frying and can also be consumed raw.

3. Pepperoncini Peppers

Pepperoncini peppers are the right choice to make in place of pickled banana peppers if you’re seeking for an alternative to pickles. Pepperoncini peppers are one of the very few varieties of chili peppers that are indigenous to Italy. These peppers are often bought pickled and preserved in jars.

Although they are somewhat smaller than banana peppers, their sweetness is an exact replica. Although they have a taste that is more tangy than that of banana peppers, they are not quite as hot as banana peppers. Your pepperoncini peppers that have been pickled may be used as a topping, or you can enjoy them as a side dish.

4. Anaheim Peppers

An additional kind of pepper that is often used in stuffing recipes, anaheim peppers are the pepper that most closely resembles banana peppers in both size and form. Although they are only slightly smaller than banana peppers, you may use them in lieu of banana peppers in any setting.

In addition to being sweet, Anaheim peppers have a taste that is similar to that of bell peppers. The fact that anaheim peppers and banana peppers both contain a touch of heat is the sole important distinction between the two varieties. However, with a Scoville heat level ranging from just 500 to 2,500, they cannot in any way be described as being spicy.

5. Jalapeño Peppers

Jalapeo peppers, which are one of the most common types of chili peppers and can be found just about everywhere in the globe, are an ideal replacement for banana peppers. Even though jalapeo peppers are somewhat smaller than banana peppers, they are an excellent choice for stuffing, pickling, and using as a topping. They also do not have the same level of sweetness as banana peppers and have a taste that is more earthy.

Having said that, the Scoville heat rating of jalapeo peppers ranges anywhere from 2,500 to 8,000 units. Even though they are not the spiciest chili peppers, they still have some kick to them. Therefore, if you’re not a fan of things being too spicy, utilize these peppers with caution.


What pepper is closest to a banana pepper?

Green bell peppers are the kind of bell pepper that most closely resembles banana peppers, both in appearance and taste. This is true for both green bell peppers and banana peppers. This is true for green bell peppers as well as yellow ones.

Is pepperoncini same as banana peppers?

The amount of heat that each pepperoncini and banana pepper has is the primary distinction between the two.

Are banana peppers just yellow peppers?

The banana pepper, sometimes called the yellow wax pepper or banana chili, is a member of the chili pepper family that is about the size of a banana and has a flavor that is somewhere between mild and tart. It is possible for them to transform into green, red, or orange as they mature, even though they are normally a brilliant yellow color.

Are banana peppers and sweet peppers the same?

What Kind of Peppers Are Sweet Peppers? The word “sweet pepper” refers to a variety of peppers that have a low level of heat and a fruity or sweet taste. Examples of sweet peppers are bell peppers, pimentos, and banana peppers. These colorful peppers are a member of the Capsicum genus, which also includes other fiery peppers such as paprika, habaneros, and jalapenos.

Are banana peppers hotter than jalapeno?

There is no truth to the claim that banana peppers are spicier than jalapenos. In point of fact, they are a lot, lot less severe. The Scoville Heat Index value for raw banana peppers ranges from 0 to 500 SHU, which indicates that they are not very spicy and provide just a little tingling sensation on the tongue. The Scoville heat units of jalapenos may vary anywhere from 1,500 to 10,000, depending on the type.

Are banana peppers Anaheim peppers?

The growth rate of an anaheim pepper is much lower than that of a banana pepper, and an anaheim pepper is also somewhat smaller. When compared to anaheim bushes, banana pepper plants will often grow to be 10 centimeters higher and 7-8 centimeters broader.

Can I sub banana peppers for pepperoncini?

Because of the striking similarity in flavor, banana peppers are often considered to be the greatest alternative to pepperoncini. What is this, exactly? Both of these peppers fall into the same area on the Scoville scale due to their low levels of heat. Because of how similar these two peppers are to one another, they are often given the wrong names at grocery stores.


When cooking a meal, everyone of us has felt the dread that comes with the realization that an essential component of the recipe is missing from our kitchen. However, if the banana pepper is the only thing that’s lacking, there’s still a chance. Any of the items on our list that may serve as a replacement for banana peppers will do an excellent job, guaranteeing that your meal will continue to be a highlight.