What Is the Greatest Replacement for Tomato Paste?

Rate this post

Tomato paste is a popular and flavorful ingredient that can be found in recipes for lunches, dinners, and even baking. It’s a thick paste created by slow-cooking tomatoes for many hours to minimize the water content, resulting in a thick, richly flavored concentration that may be used in pasta sauces, soups, and other dishes.

Occasionally you’ll come across a recipe that calls for tomato paste, or you’ll need a substitution for whatever reason.

This post will look at the finest tomato paste replacements for each case. Continue reading to learn all you need to know.

What Is Tomato Paste?

Tomato paste is prepared by slow-cooking and reducing refined tomatoes. When they have completed boiling and cooled, the skins and seeds are removed by filtering.

This technique produces wonderful concentrated tastes, making tomato paste one of the most significant culinary components for hundreds of dishes.

Tomato paste has a thick consistency that may be diluted down for sauces or used to thicken other sauces for pizza bases. It is most often used to thicken sauces, soups, and stews while also adding flavor at a low cost.

What Can You Substitute For Tomato Paste?

Substitute: Good For:
Tomato Sauce Stewed tomatoes, sauces, and soups.
Tomato Puree Soups, Chili, Lasagna.
Crushed Tomatoes Thickening sauces, soups, and beef stews.
Marinara Sauce Pasta dishes that require a sauce.
Ketchup Spaghetti.
Nomato Sauce People with tomato allergies.

1. Tomato Sauce

Genuine tomato sauce is a recipe used to make great pasta, stews, and other foods. In such cases, it’s an excellent alternative for tomato paste.

Tomato sauce often uses tomato puree or paste to thicken the sauce, however cornstarch may also be used to thicken the sauce.

When creating tomato sauce at home, the second alternative is to simmer it for a longer period of time. Slow-cooking tomatoes is an important step in creating tomato paste because it allows the water content to drop.

2. Tomato Puree

When it comes to tomato paste replacements, tomato puree, also known as passata, ranks high.

To substitute puree for paste, use twice as much puree as tomato paste. Substitute a tablespoon of water for each tablespoon of tomato puree in your recipe.

What’s the difference between tomato puree and tomato paste?

Tomato puree is more liquid than tomato paste, but it retains a rich tomatoey taste that makes it useful as the foundation for many sauces and for thickening items like soup.

3. Crushed Tomatoes

If you have canned diced tomatoes or canned plum tomatoes on hand, you can prepare crushed tomatoes in approximately five minutes.

  • Open two or three cans of canned tomatoes.
  • They may be blended in a food processor or crushed by hand.
  • Pour them into a pan.
  • Slowly boil this combination for as long as you can to make a crushed tomato substitute for the tomato paste.

Check watch this video to learn how to prepare crushed tomatoes from fresh tomatoes.

As an alternative for tomato paste, you may use either canned or fresh crushed tomatoes. When it comes to cooking, fresh is nearly always preferable than tinned, but canned is still a viable option.

4. Marinara Sauce

Marinara sauce is a popular Italian sauce prepared with fresh tomatoes, onions, garlic, olive oil, and oregano.

Because of all the components, the sauce has a medium-thick consistency and a lot of texture. It does, however, make a great tomato paste substitute for spaghetti and other pasta recipes.

One advantage of utilizing marinara sauce over a basic tomato paste is that it is highly flavorful and adds a lot of depth of flavor to your food.

5. Ketchup

Although ketchup may occasionally be used in place of tomato paste, bear in mind that it is a condiment. Since it is not an ingredient, it is not suitable for cooking.

When you need something quick and cheap, you may substitute ketchup for tomato paste in spaghetti.

6. Nomato Sauce

For those who are allergic to nightshades, Nomato Sauce is an excellent replacement for tomato paste. In fact, many individuals who cannot eat tomatoes are unaware of this excellent sauce.

Beets, onions, garlic, carrots, white wine vinegar, and balsamic vinegar may all be used to produce this sauce. This is then sautéed in a little oil. After the mixture has reached the desired consistency, purée it in a food processor.


There are several reasons why you may want a tomato paste substitute. In any case, one of the replacements listed above will work well in place of tomato paste in any recipe.


What has similar taste to tomato paste?

Best Tomato Paste Substitutes You Should Try
In terms of moisture content and strength, ketchup comes closest to tomato paste.
Tomato sauce has a similar taste to tomato paste but a thicker viscosity.
Tomato puree tastes the same as tomato paste.
In a can, crushed tomatoes are either chopped or whole.
Additional details…•March 2, 2023

What happens if you use tomato sauce instead of tomato paste?

Tomato sauce is thinner than tomato puree, but both will work. Since these items are less concentrated than tomato paste, you’ll need at least twice as much to achieve the same level of tomato flavor as tomato paste.

How much tomato paste in a tube equals a can of tomato paste?

If your recipe asks for a whole 6 ounce can of regular tomato paste, use 3 ounces double concentrated tomato paste.

Can I use marinara instead of tomato paste?

As an alternative to tomato paste, try marinara sauce.

Marinara sauce already has a similar consistency to tomato paste, but it should only be used in dishes where the remainder of the marinara sauce’s components, particularly Italian spices, will not interfere with or overshadow whatever meal you’re cooking.

Is tomato paste just crushed tomatoes?

Ingredients. Tomato paste is essentially tomato sauce that has been reduced until the liquid has evaporated and a thick paste has formed. As a result, the only thing you truly need is tomato sauce. It may be canned or homemade fresh tomato sauce.

How much ketchup to substitute for tomato paste?

Indeed, ketchup is a surprisingly good substitute for tomato paste! Since ketchup is already rather concentrated, you may use a 1:1 substitution from the bottle (if your recipe calls for one tablespoon of tomato paste, use one tablespoon of ketchup).

Is tomato paste just tomato sauce?

Despite the fact that both are pantry staples produced from cooked and strained tomatoes, tomato paste is a thick tomato concentrate, and tomato sauce is a thick tomato sauce.

Is tomato sauce just watered down tomato paste?

Tomato Sauce vs. Tomato Paste

Tomato paste is prepared by heating tomatoes and removing their seeds and liquids until all that is left is a highly concentrated, very thick product with strong tomato taste. However, tomato sauce is often produced with a lot of aromatics and has a thinner texture.

Should I use tomato sauce or tomato paste?

Tomato sauce is often used on its own in meals such as spaghetti or lasagna. Tomato paste is used to provide depth of flavor to soups and stews as a foundation or seasoning. It is distinguished from tomato sauce by its deeper and more powerful taste, as well as its darker red color.

Is tube tomato paste better than canned?

If you’re making a recipe that requires a considerable quantity of tomato paste, go for the can. The tube is the way to go if you just need a spoonful or two.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *